Gold Au $3541.00 $0.00
Silver Ag $41.33 $0.00
Platinum Pt $1306.00 $0.00
Palladium Pd $899.00 $0.00

We ship in 1-2 business days

Sell baseball cards · Nutley, NJ

Sell Baseball Cards in Nutley, NJ

We buy baseball cards at our Nutley shop, from 1950s Topps to today's Bowman Chrome prospects. Bring in a binder, a box or a few slabs, and we'll go through them with you and make an offer based on recent sales.

  • By appointment in Nutley
  • Priced on recent sales
  • Paid the same visit
  • No obligation to sell

Baseball cards we buy

Vintage Topps & Bowman

1950s–1970s stars, Hall of Famers and rookies.

Rookie cards

Topps, Topps Chrome, Bowman and other licensed rookies.

Bowman 1st prospects

1st Bowman cards and autos, including numbered refractors.

Autographs & parallels

On-card autos, low-numbered parallels and 1/1s.

Graded baseball

PSA, BGS, SGC and CGC slabs, vintage and modern.

Sets & collections

Complete sets and large collections.

Rookie cards vs. Bowman 1st prospect cards

Baseball is different from other sports. Players often get cards years before they reach the majors. Their first licensed card in a Bowman product is marked "1st Bowman", and collectors chase these hard, especially autographed and low-numbered Chrome refractors.

A player's official rookie card, with the RC logo, comes out when he reaches the majors. For established stars, both the Bowman 1st and the rookie card can be valuable. For prospects who never make it, Bowman 1st prices can fall a long way, which is why we price them on very recent sales.

Vintage is a different market. For 1950s–1970s cards, the player, the year and the condition drive the price, and stars and Hall of Famers are worth looking at even with some wear.

Key baseball card types

CardWhat it is
1st BowmanA player's first licensed card, often before the majors
Rookie card (RC)Official rookie-year card after his MLB debut
Chrome refractorShiny parallel, often serial numbered
Vintage starPre-1980 Hall of Famer or star

How selling baseball cards works

  1. Send a quick list or photos

    Call 201-242-2646 with what you have: players or Pokémon, sets, slabs and roughly how many.

  2. Bring the cards in

    Book a time and bring a valid photo ID. Sellers must be 18 or older. Keep raw cards sleeved and leave slabs as they are.

  3. We check comps and condition

    Slabs are verified by cert number. Raw cards are checked for centering, corners, edges and surface.

  4. Get an offer, card by card

    We show the recent sales we used. Sell the whole lot or just some, and get paid the same visit by cash, check or wire.

Selling baseball cards in Nutley

Our shop is at 87 Franklin Ave in the center of Nutley, close to Route 21 and the Garden State Parkway. Collectors come in from Belleville, Bloomfield, Clifton, Lyndhurst and across North Jersey.

Call 201-242-2646 to book a time. A list or photos of your best cards helps us check recent sales before you arrive.

Sellers often visit us from

  • Nutley
  • Belleville
  • Bloomfield
  • Clifton
  • Glen Ridge
  • Montclair
  • Lyndhurst
  • North Arlington
  • Kearny
  • Passaic

Frequently asked questions

Yes. 1950s–1970s Topps and Bowman, especially stars, Hall of Famers and rookies, raw or graded.

Most base cards from those years were printed in huge numbers and are worth little. Key rookies in high grades, inserts and some errors can be worth more.

A player's first licensed card in a Bowman product, often issued before he reaches the majors. Autographed and numbered versions are the most valuable.

Yes. PSA, BGS, SGC and CGC slabs, vintage and modern.

Get an offer at our Nutley shop

Call ahead to book a time. We look at everything with you at the counter, explain the offer, and you decide.

Coin Superstore LLC
87 Franklin Ave, Nutley, NJ 07110
201-242-2646
Mon–Fri 10am–5pm ET · by appointment
Get directions