0 items in Cart
Your cart is empty
Navigating the world of graded Pokemon cards isn't just about finding a buyer, it's about finding the right expert to trust with your collection. Whether you're a longtime collector seeking a fair market offer on PSA 10 Charizards or you've recently inherited an estate of graded Pokemon cards and need clear, honest advice, Coin Superstore has become the region's trusted source for variety, value, and service. Based in Nutley, NJ, and serving clients throughout the Newark metropolitan area and nationwide via our online shop and eBay store, we specialize in buying, evaluating, and appraising certified Pokemon cards from PCGS, PSA, Beckett, and more. As a PCGS Authorized Dealer, our reputation is built on transparent deals, deep knowledge, and professionalism every step of the way.
Selling graded Pokemon cards can feel daunting, but with Coin Superstore, every client receives clarity and respect from start to finish. Explore our tailored buying services designed for both local collectors and national sellers:
We provide immediate, market-accurate cash offers for all third-party graded Pokemon cards, including PSA, CGC, BGS, and SGC slabs. Our team reviews card grade (such as PSA 9 or PSA 10), set, and desirability to determine a competitive offer. You can bring your cards in for a walk-in evaluation at our Nutley location, or reach out for a quote online or by phone.
Whether you're handling a single rare card or a full estate collection, our professional appraisal service walks you through the process step by step. We leverage experience in third-party grading, covering terms like Gem Mint 10, NM-MT 8, and more, to provide honest, thorough assessments. Every appraisal results in a written evaluation documenting condition, grading, market trends, and potential value. There's no pressure to sell: our priority is giving peace of mind rooted in expertise.
Collectors and estate sellers alike appreciate our discretion and ability to handle entire graded Pokemon card collections. No need to parse out your holdings or sort cards by certifier: we're prepared to purchase bulk lots spanning all modern and vintage sets, from Base Set holos to Japanese promo slabs. Estate sellers will find our approach transparent and patient, allowing for careful review of inherited assets.
Your safety and your cards' security are top priorities. Local clients can visit our storefront for face-to-face service at 87 Franklin Ave in Nutley, just minutes from Newark and surrounding towns. National collectors can use our secure mail-in buying service, with insured shipping, transparent communication, and prompt payment upon receipt and evaluation. Most packages ship within 1–2 business days: shipping fees typically range from $15–$40, depending on value and volume. Each transaction is handled by our experienced staff, ensuring accuracy and integrity throughout the process.
Your choice of Pokemon card buyer matters for more than price, it's about professionalism, trust, and expertise. Here's why collectors and estate sellers in New Jersey and across the country choose Coin Superstore:
Coin Superstore welcomes Pokemon card sellers from across the Newark metro area, including Nutley, Belleville, Bloomfield, Clifton, Montclair, Lyndhurst, and surrounding North Jersey communities. Our in-store buying and appraisal service is a short drive from destinations across Essex, Bergen, and Passaic counties.
We also serve collectors nationwide through our website and eBay store (coinsuperstore9). If you're outside New Jersey or can't visit in person, our mail-in process makes it simple and secure to sell certified Pokemon cards from anywhere in the United States. Just reach out for shipping instructions and a preliminary offer.
Whether you're five minutes from our Nutley storefront or hundreds of miles away, Coin Superstore delivers the same level of trustworthy service and expertise.
If you're considering selling graded Pokemon cards, whether it's a single PSA 10, a mixed collection, or a full estate lot, Coin Superstore is ready to assist with the honesty and expertise collectors value most.
For immediate help, call our team at (201) 242-2646, use the contact form on CoinSuperstore.com, or visit our store in Nutley, NJ. We're happy to explain our process, answer questions about card grading, and provide a no-obligation evaluation.
You are always welcome to stop by during posted hours, or begin the sale with a simple photo and item list, no need to second-guess what's valuable or how to start. From your first question to payment, you'll find Coin Superstore offers transparent guidance and genuine respect for your collection.
Coin Superstore LLC
87 Franklin Ave, Nutley, NJ 07110
Phone: (201) 242-2646
eBay: coinsuperstore9
Instagram: @thecoinsuperstore
Store Hours:
Monday–Friday: 10:00 am – 6:00 pm
Saturday: 10:00 am – 3:00 pm
Sunday: Closed
Coin Superstore is a PCGS Authorized Dealer and NGC Coin Dealer Locator listed business serving the Newark metro, Northern New Jersey, and beyond. We buy and appraise coins, bullion, currency, diamonds, jewelry, watches, and graded Pokemon cards. Walk-ins are always welcome, and collectors from across the country can connect with our staff online or by phone.
Experience why we're the collector's trusted source for variety, value, and service.