Gold Au $3541.00 $0.00
Silver Ag $41.33 $0.00
Platinum Pt $1306.00 $0.00
Palladium Pd $899.00 $0.00

We ship in 1-2 business days

Graded card buyer · Nutley, NJ

Graded Card Buyer in Nutley, NJ

We buy graded baseball, basketball, football and Pokémon cards at our shop on Franklin Ave. Bring your PSA, BGS, SGC, CGC or TAG slabs and we'll price each one on recent sales, not guesses.

  • By appointment in Nutley
  • Priced on recent sales
  • Paid the same visit
  • No obligation to sell

Graded cards we buy

Baseball

Vintage Topps and Bowman, and modern rookies, autos and parallels.

Basketball

Fleer, Topps Chrome, Prizm, Select and National Treasures rookies.

Football

Rookie cards, rookie patch autos and vintage stars.

Vintage stars

Pre-1980 Hall of Famers in baseball, basketball and football.

Pokémon

Vintage WOTC, modern alt arts and Japanese cards.

Graded lots

Graded runs, team collections and whole slab boxes.

How we price a graded card

A graded card's value comes from three things: the card, the grade and the grader. The same card in PSA 10 and PSA 9 can be worth very different amounts, and a BGS 9.5 or a CGC 10 can trade differently from a PSA 10.

We price slabs on recent sold results for that exact card, grade and grader, not on asking prices. We verify each slab's cert number, look at the holder for damage or tampering, and then make an offer. If a card is a better fit for auction than for a dealer, we'll tell you.

Grading companies we buy

GraderScaleKnown for
PSA1–10Most traded slabs for sports and Pokémon
BGS (Beckett)1–10 with subgradesBlack Label and 9.5 premiums
SGC1–10Vintage baseball and football
CGC1–10Strong in Pokémon
TAG1–10Newer, scored-grading slabs

We buy other slabs too. Value depends on the grader as well as the number.

How selling cards works

  1. Send a quick list or photos

    Call 201-242-2646 with what you have: players or Pokémon, sets, slabs and roughly how many.

  2. Bring the cards in

    Book a time and bring a valid photo ID. Sellers must be 18 or older. Keep raw cards sleeved and leave slabs as they are.

  3. We check comps and condition

    Slabs are verified by cert number. Raw cards are checked for centering, corners, edges and surface.

  4. Get an offer, card by card

    We show the recent sales we used. Sell the whole lot or just some, and get paid the same visit by cash, check or wire.

Selling graded cards in Nutley

Our shop at 87 Franklin Ave is easy to reach from all of Nutley and from Belleville, Bloomfield, Clifton and Lyndhurst. You'll be dealing face to face at a counter instead of shipping slabs to a buyer you've never met.

We see sellers by appointment. Call 201-242-2646 with a rough list of what you have, and we can often tell you on the phone whether it's worth bringing in.

Sellers often visit us from

  • Nutley
  • Belleville
  • Bloomfield
  • Clifton
  • Lyndhurst
  • Montclair
  • Glen Ridge
  • North Arlington

Frequently asked questions

PSA, BGS, SGC, CGC and TAG, plus other slabs on a case-by-case basis.

Yes. We buy raw sports and Pokémon cards as well as graded ones.

Yes. Vintage cards in low grades can still be valuable. Modern cards in low grades usually aren't worth much, and we'll be upfront about that.

As a dealer we pay below retail so we can resell. We show you the recent sales we used so you can see the margin.

Get an offer at our Nutley shop

Call ahead to book a time. We look at everything with you at the counter, explain the offer, and you decide.

Coin Superstore LLC
87 Franklin Ave, Nutley, NJ 07110
201-242-2646
Mon–Fri 10am–5pm ET · by appointment
Get directions