Gold Au $3541.00 $0.00
Silver Ag $41.33 $0.00
Platinum Pt $1306.00 $0.00
Palladium Pd $899.00 $0.00

We ship in 1-2 business days

Sell football cards · Essex County

Sell Football Cards Near Essex County, NJ

We're an Essex County shop in Nutley, and we buy football cards from every era. A lot of what we see locally is vintage: Topps and Bowman cards from the 1950s through the '80s, often in shoeboxes or partly built sets. Here's what makes them valuable.

  • By appointment in Nutley
  • Priced on recent sales
  • Paid the same visit
  • No obligation to sell

Football cards we buy

1950s–60s Topps & Bowman

Stars, rookies and high-number cards.

1970s–80s football

Hall of Fame rookies and key stars.

Vintage sets

Complete and partial sets, sorted or not.

Graded vintage

PSA, SGC and BGS vintage slabs.

Modern rookies & autos

Prizm, Optic, National Treasures and RPAs.

Numbered parallels

Low-numbered colors and 1/1s.

What makes vintage football cards valuable

Hall of Famers and their rookie cards come first. A Hall of Fame quarterback's rookie card from the '50s, '60s or '70s can be worth a lot even with some wear. Common players from the same years are usually worth much less.

Condition is harder to find in vintage. Older cards were printed off-center, stored loose and handled a lot. Sharp corners, good centering and clean surfaces are rare, which is why high-grade vintage carries such a premium. Mid-grade cards still sell well when the player is a star.

Sets are worth keeping together. A complete or nearly complete vintage set can be worth more as a set than as individual cards, especially when the key rookies are in it. Don't pull the stars out before we see it.

Before you bring vintage cards

  • Don't clean, trim or press cards.
  • Keep sets in order if they're already sorted.
  • Put the best cards in sleeves or top loaders.
  • Don't write on cards or use rubber bands.
  • Note any cards kept separately.

How selling football cards works

  1. Send a quick list or photos

    Call 201-242-2646 with what you have: players or Pokémon, sets, slabs and roughly how many.

  2. Bring the cards in

    Book a time and bring a valid photo ID. Sellers must be 18 or older. Keep raw cards sleeved and leave slabs as they are.

  3. We check comps and condition

    Slabs are verified by cert number. Raw cards are checked for centering, corners, edges and surface.

  4. Get an offer, card by card

    We show the recent sales we used. Sell the whole lot or just some, and get paid the same visit by cash, check or wire.

Selling football cards in Essex County

Nutley sits in the northeast corner of Essex County. From Bloomfield, Belleville and Montclair you're minutes away. From West Orange, Livingston and the Caldwells, take I-280 east to the Garden State Parkway north. From Newark, Route 21 north comes straight into town. We're at 87 Franklin Ave.

Call 201-242-2646 to book a time. If you're bringing sets or a full collection, let us know so we can plan enough time.

Sellers often visit us from

  • Newark
  • Montclair
  • Bloomfield
  • Belleville
  • Nutley
  • West Orange
  • East Orange
  • Livingston
  • Verona
  • Cedar Grove
  • Caldwell
  • Maplewood
  • South Orange
  • Millburn

Frequently asked questions

Yes. 1950s–1980s Topps and Bowman football, stars, rookies and sets, raw or graded.

Often, yes, if the player is a star or a Hall of Famer. Commons in poor condition are usually worth little.

A complete or near-complete vintage set is often worth more together. We'll tell you which works better.

Yes. Rookies, autos, RPAs and numbered parallels, raw or graded.

Get an offer at our Nutley shop

Call ahead to book a time. We look at everything with you at the counter, explain the offer, and you decide.

Coin Superstore LLC
87 Franklin Ave, Nutley, NJ 07110
201-242-2646
Mon–Fri 10am–5pm ET · by appointment
Get directions