Gold Au $3541.00 $0.00
Silver Ag $41.33 $0.00
Platinum Pt $1306.00 $0.00
Palladium Pd $899.00 $0.00

We ship in 1-2 business days

Sell football cards · Near Morris County

Sell Football Cards Near Morris County, NJ

In football cards, the rookie card is almost always the one that matters most. But a player can have dozens of cards in his first year, and not all of them count the same. We buy football cards at our Nutley shop and will help you figure out which ones you have.

  • By appointment in Nutley
  • Priced on recent sales
  • Paid the same visit
  • No obligation to sell

Football cards we buy

True rookie cards

First-year cards with the RC logo from licensed sets.

Rookie autos & RPAs

On-card autos and patch autos from the rookie year.

Premium rookies

National Treasures, Flawless, Contenders and Prizm.

Numbered parallels

Low-numbered colors and 1/1s.

Vintage stars

Pre-1990 Hall of Famers and rookies.

Graded football

PSA, BGS, SGC and CGC slabs.

What counts as a rookie card?

A player's rookie card is a card from his first year, in a licensed set, usually marked with an RC logo. These are the cards collectors want most, and the ones that move most with a player's career.

Not every early card is a true rookie. Pre-rookie and draft cards, such as college uniform cards from before the player's first season, are generally worth less. Second-year cards are usually worth much less than the rookie year. Inserts without the RC logo can be valuable, but often less than the main rookie cards.

Within a player's rookie year, the most valuable cards are on-card autographs, patch autos (RPAs) and low serial numbers in premium brands, followed by the flagship rookie from sets like Prizm and Optic.

Rookie or not?

CardUsually
First-year card with RC logoTrue rookie, most valuable
Rookie-year auto or RPATop of the market
College or pre-draft cardPre-rookie, worth less
Second-year cardWorth much less

How selling football cards works

  1. Send a quick list or photos

    Call 201-242-2646 with what you have: players or Pokémon, sets, slabs and roughly how many.

  2. Bring the cards in

    Book a time and bring a valid photo ID. Sellers must be 18 or older. Keep raw cards sleeved and leave slabs as they are.

  3. We check comps and condition

    Slabs are verified by cert number. Raw cards are checked for centering, corners, edges and surface.

  4. Get an offer, card by card

    We show the recent sales we used. Sell the whole lot or just some, and get paid the same visit by cash, check or wire.

Coming in from Morris County

From Morristown and Morris Plains, I-287 to I-280 east and the Parkway north brings you to Nutley. From Parsippany, Boonton and Lincoln Park, I-80 east to the Parkway south is quicker. Either way, we're at 87 Franklin Ave, near the Parkway and Route 21.

Football card prices move during the season. Call 201-242-2646 before you come so we can look up the latest sales.

Sellers often visit us from

  • Parsippany
  • Morristown
  • Montville
  • Boonton
  • Denville
  • Rockaway
  • Randolph
  • Madison
  • Chatham
  • Florham Park
  • Morris Plains
  • East Hanover
  • Lincoln Park

Frequently asked questions

Look for an RC logo on a first-year card from a licensed set. If you're not sure, bring it in and we'll check.

Some are, for star players, but they're usually worth less than the player's true rookie cards.

Yes. We buy raw and graded cards.

Yes. Offers are based on recent sales and are good for the day we make them.

Get an offer at our Nutley shop

Call ahead to book a time. We look at everything with you at the counter, explain the offer, and you decide.

Coin Superstore LLC
87 Franklin Ave, Nutley, NJ 07110
201-242-2646
Mon–Fri 10am–5pm ET · by appointment
Get directions