0 items in Cart
Rare coin dealer · Near Bergen County
Coin Superstore buys and sells rare US and world coins from our shop in Nutley, just across the Passaic from south Bergen County. Whether you're building a set, selling one coin or settling a collection, you'll be working with dealers who handle certified and raw coins every day.
See what's in stock in our rare US coins listings.
Key dates, Carson City issues, proof-likes and certified high grades.
Bust and Seated coinage, Barber coins, large cents and half cents.
$1 through $20 Liberty and Indian gold and Saint-Gaudens double eagles.
Classic 1892–1954 silver and gold commemoratives and modern issues.
PCGS, NGC, CAC and other slabbed coins in any grade.
World gold and silver, crowns and US and world banknotes.
Age alone doesn't make a coin valuable. Value comes from a mix of mintage (how many were made), survival (how many are left), condition (grade), and demand (how many collectors want one). A common 1921 Morgan dollar trades close to its silver value, while a 1893-S in the same grade sells for many thousands.
Mint marks and varieties matter just as much. Small letters, doubled dies and overdates can multiply a coin's value, and they're easy to miss without a loupe and a reference. We check each coin for date, mint mark, variety and grade before pricing it.
For valuable raw coins, we'll also tell you whether sending them to PCGS or NGC for grading is likely to pay off, or whether you'd do better selling them as they are.
Call 201-242-2646 with a rough idea: a few coins, a set, a whole collection or an estate.
Bring a valid photo ID (18+). Leave coins as they are: don't clean them or take them out of holders or albums.
We identify date, mint mark, variety and condition and check current dealer and auction prices.
Bullion is priced from today's spot, rare coins from the market. Sell what you want and keep the rest.
Our shop at 87 Franklin Ave, Nutley, is a short drive from Lyndhurst, North Arlington and Rutherford across the river. Collectors from Hackensack, Paramus and the Route 17 corridor typically take Route 17 south to Route 3 west and Route 21 into Nutley.
We work by appointment, which gives us time to go through a collection with you properly. Tell us what you have when you call and we'll set aside enough time.
Call ahead to book a time. We look at everything with you at the counter, explain the offer, and you decide.