Gold Au $3541.00 $0.00
Silver Ag $41.33 $0.00
Platinum Pt $1306.00 $0.00
Palladium Pd $899.00 $0.00

We ship in 1-2 business days

Graded Card Buyer Near Bergen County, NJ


Graded card buyer · Near Bergen County

Graded Card Buyer Near Bergen County, NJ

Bergen County collectors bring us everything from vintage Mantles to modern Prizm rookies. If you're selling slabs, it helps to know what moves a graded card's value. Here's how we look at it, and how to get your cards to us in Nutley.

  • By appointment in Nutley
  • Priced on recent sales
  • Paid the same visit
  • No obligation to sell

Graded cards we're buying

Vintage baseball

1950s–1980s Topps, Bowman and stars in PSA and SGC holders.

Modern rookies

Prizm, Optic, Chrome and Bowman Chrome rookies in high grades.

Autos & patches

On-card autos, RPAs and numbered parallels.

Football & basketball stars

Hall of Famers and current stars, vintage and modern.

Pokémon slabs

WOTC vintage and modern chase cards.

Slab collections

Graded team runs, player collections and set builds.

What moves a graded card's value

Grade gaps. For many modern cards, almost all of the value sits at the top grade. A PSA 10 can be worth several times a PSA 9. For vintage cards, the steps between grades are smaller and mid-grade cards still sell well.

Population. Grading companies publish how many copies they've graded at each grade. A card with only a few 10s commands more than one with thousands. We check the population reports as part of every offer.

Grader. The same grade from different companies can sell at different prices, depending on the card and the era. Eye appeal matters too: two cards in the same grade can still sell differently if one has better centering or color.

What we check on every slab

  • Cert number, looked up with the grading company
  • Holder condition: cracks, scratches or signs of tampering
  • Population at this grade and above
  • Recent sold prices for this card, grade and grader
  • Centering and eye appeal within the grade

How selling cards works

  1. Send a quick list or photos

    Call 201-242-2646 with what you have: players or Pokémon, sets, slabs and roughly how many.

  2. Bring the cards in

    Book a time and bring a valid photo ID. Sellers must be 18 or older. Keep raw cards sleeved and leave slabs as they are.

  3. We check comps and condition

    Slabs are verified by cert number. Raw cards are checked for centering, corners, edges and surface.

  4. Get an offer, card by card

    We show the recent sales we used. Sell the whole lot or just some, and get paid the same visit by cash, check or wire.

Selling slabs from Bergen County

Our Nutley shop is just across the Passaic from Lyndhurst and North Arlington. From Hackensack, Paramus and the Route 17 corridor, take Route 17 south to Route 3 west and Route 21 into Nutley. We're at 87 Franklin Ave.

Bringing a big box of slabs? Send us a list or a few photos first so we can look up comps before you arrive and keep the visit short.

Sellers often visit us from

  • Hackensack
  • Paramus
  • Teaneck
  • Fort Lee
  • Ridgewood
  • Rutherford
  • Lyndhurst
  • East Rutherford
  • Fair Lawn
  • Englewood
  • Garfield
  • Bergenfield
  • Wyckoff

Frequently asked questions

Yes. One slab or a hundred, the process is the same.

Yes. Send a list or photos with grades and cert numbers and we can research them ahead of time.

Sometimes. A damaged holder may need to be re-graded, which affects the offer. We'll explain your options.

Yes, especially certified autos and slabs with authenticated autographs.

Get an offer at our Nutley shop

Call ahead to book a time. We look at everything with you at the counter, explain the offer, and you decide.

Coin Superstore LLC
87 Franklin Ave, Nutley, NJ 07110
201-242-2646
Mon–Fri 10am–5pm ET · by appointment
Get directions