0 items in Cart
Gold buying & selling · Nutley, NJ
Coin Superstore buys and sells gold coins, bars and rounds from our shop at 87 Franklin Ave. Whether you're adding to a position or cashing out, you deal with the same people at the same counter, with prices tied to the live gold market.
We stock popular bullion and buy it back. Browse what's in stock on our gold bullion page.
1 oz and fractional Eagles and .9999 Buffalos, the most-traded US bullion coins.
1 oz and fractional .9999 Maples, plus Krugerrands, Britannias and Philharmonics.
PAMP, Valcambi, Perth Mint and other assay bars, from 1 gram up to kilo bars.
Liberty and Saint-Gaudens double eagles, Indians and other classic US gold, raw or certified.
Mexican 50 Pesos, British Sovereigns, French Roosters and other circulated world gold.
Karat jewelry, dental gold and broken pieces, bought by weight and purity.
Every gold price you'll see starts with spot, the live market price for one troy ounce. When you buy, you pay spot plus a premium that covers minting, distribution and the dealer. When you sell, you're paid spot or a little under for common bullion. The gap between the two is the spread, and a smaller spread means you keep more.
Premiums are lowest on larger bars and widely known coins and highest on small fractional pieces and special editions. If you're buying to hold gold as metal, 1 oz coins and bars usually give the most gold per dollar. If you'd like coins that may also carry collector value, ask us about pre-1933 US gold, which often trades close to bullion in circulated grades.
Selling? Bring the coins or bars in their original packaging or assay cards if you still have them. It isn't required, but it makes bars quicker to verify and can help with resale value.
We're happy to explain any quote before you commit.
We work by appointment. Call 201-242-2646 or book online, and bring a valid photo ID. Sellers must be 18 or older.
Each piece is checked for karat or fineness and weighed on a certified scale while you watch.
We show weight, purity and the day's gold price for each piece, so you can see how the number was reached.
If the offer works for you, you're paid during the same visit by cash, check or wire, depending on the amount. If not, you take everything home.
Coin Superstore is at 87 Franklin Ave in the center of Nutley, close to Route 21 and the Garden State Parkway. Many of our gold customers come from Nutley and the towns that border it. Others drive in from across North Jersey because they'd rather deal face to face than ship bullion to an online dealer.
We work by appointment so we're ready when you arrive and there's no waiting at the counter. Call ahead, tell us roughly what you'd like to buy or sell, and we'll have current prices ready.
Call ahead to book a time. We look at everything with you at the counter, explain the offer, and you decide.