0 items in Cart
Sell rare coins · Near Bergen County
There's more than one way to sell rare coins: a dealer, an auction house or an online marketplace. Each has its place. We'll explain the trade-offs honestly, and if selling to a dealer makes sense for your coins, we'll make you an offer at our Nutley shop, just across the Passaic from Bergen County.
Key dates, Carson City coins, proof-likes and certified high grades.
PCGS, NGC and CAC coins in any grade.
Liberty, Indian and Saint-Gaudens gold, raw or certified.
Bust, Seated and Barber coinage, large cents and half cents.
Lincoln, Buffalo, Mercury, Walking Liberty and other sets.
Gold, silver and better world coins and banknotes.
Auction can bring the highest prices for truly rare, high-grade coins, because many bidders compete. But auctions charge seller's fees, the coins may wait weeks or months for the right sale, and payment comes after that. For common or mid-range coins, the fees can eat most of the advantage.
Selling online yourself can work for single coins, but you take on photos, listings, fees, shipping risk and returns, and buyers often discount raw coins they can't see in hand.
Selling to a dealer is the fastest and simplest: one visit, one offer, paid the same day. Our offer is below retail because we have to resell the coins, but there are no fees and no waiting. For most collections, that trade-off works out well. If we think a coin would do much better at auction, we'll tell you.
| Dealer | Auction | Online | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Speed | Same visit | Weeks to months | Varies |
| Fees | None | Seller's fees | Platform fees |
| Your work | One visit | Consign and wait | List, ship, handle returns |
| Best for | Most coins | Top rarities | Single coins |
Call 201-242-2646 with a rough idea: a few coins, a set, a whole collection or an estate.
Bring a valid photo ID (18+). Leave coins as they are: don't clean them or take them out of holders or albums.
We identify date, mint mark, variety and condition and check current dealer and auction prices.
Bullion is priced from today's spot, rare coins from the market. Sell what you want and keep the rest.
Nutley borders south Bergen County along the Passaic River, so Lyndhurst, North Arlington and Rutherford are only minutes away. From Hackensack and Teaneck, Route 17 south to Route 3 west and Route 21 south is the usual drive. From Fair Lawn, Garfield and Lodi, come down Route 21 through Clifton. Our shop is at 87 Franklin Ave.
We work by appointment, which gives us time to go through your coins properly. Tell us roughly what you have when you call.
Call ahead to book a time. We look at everything with you at the counter, explain the offer, and you decide.